The Words of Agur

What Does Proverbs 30:4 Mean?

Who has ascended into heaven, or descended?Who has gathered the wind in His fists?Who has bound the waters in a garment?Who has established all the ends of the earth?What is His name, and what is His Son's name,If you know?Proverbs 30:4 · NKJV

Part of Agur's confession, Proverbs 30:1–6.

Quick answer

Six questions with one answer: not you, and not anyone you can name. The verse is not a riddle to be solved. It is a demonstration of the distance between the questioner and God.

Read the whole unit

Agur's confession moves from having no wisdom, through these questions, to the two things he will still affirm about God's word.

Read the whole unit

A new voice takes over the book here, and almost everything about him is uncertain. Agur son of Jakeh is named nowhere else in scripture. His father is unknown. The two words the NKJV reads as the names Ithiel and Ucal can be divided differently in the Hebrew consonants, which is why English versions differ so widely at verse 1, and the header word הַמַּשָּׂא can be read as a place name or as the ordinary word for an oracle. He may not have been an Israelite at all. The book of Proverbs, which has spent twenty-nine chapters teaching the fear of the LORD, hands six verses to a man whose credentials cannot be checked.

Then he opens by saying he has none. Verses 2 and 3 are not modesty. They are a denial: he did not learn wisdom, he does not have the knowledge of the Holy One, he is duller than any man. And the phrase he uses in verse 3 is the exact phrase 9:10 used for what wisdom hands you. He is standing in the wisdom book saying he does not have the wisdom book's prize.

Verse 4 explains why. Six questions, all rhetorical, all with the same answer: nobody here. Who went up to heaven and came back down, who held the wind, who tied up the water, who set the edges of the earth. The questions are Job's questions from the whirlwind and Isaiah's questions in chapter 40, and they arrive at the same place. Then the last question turns strange, asking not only for God's name but for His son's, and daring the reader to supply either.

And having established that he knows nothing, Agur says the one thing he does know. Verse 5: God's own speech has been tested and it holds. Verse 6: so do not put words in His mouth. That is the entire confession. A man with no credentials, no training and no claim ends up in the only position that was ever safe, which is holding on to what God actually said and refusing to improve it. The wisdom book's most humiliating opening produces its plainest doctrine of scripture, and the order is not an accident.

What this verse contributes

The argument's engine. Four of the questions describe things only the Creator has done, and they are the questions God Himself asks Job out of the whirlwind and the questions Isaiah asks a discouraged nation. The picture in the middle two is deliberately physical: wind held in cupped hands, seas tied up in a piece of cloth. Isaiah 40:12 asks it the same way, measuring the waters in the hollow of a hand. The point is scale, and the effect is to make the reader feel small in a way that is not an insult.

Then the fifth question changes direction. Having asked who did this, Agur asks what is he called, and adds a second name to look for. The force in context is that the reader cannot supply either one. He is not withholding a name he knows. He is closing an argument that began with "I do not have the knowledge of the Holy One" by showing that nobody in the room does.

What it does not mean

This verse is not a hidden prediction, and treating it as one costs more than it gains. A reader who has met Christ cannot come to the last line without thinking of Him, and there is nothing wrong with that; the New Testament even uses the same ascent-and-descent language, and the NKJV's own wording at John 3:13 makes the contact visible, where no one has ascended to heaven except the One who came down from it. But Agur is not naming a Son he has identified. He is naming a gap. Reading it as a coded answer reverses what the verse does, which is to leave the reader unable to answer and therefore ready for verse 5. The resonance is real and it is a resonance, not the verse's subject.

← Proverbs 30:3 All of Proverbs 30 Proverbs 30:5 →

Related: Job 38:4–11 · Isaiah 40:12 · John 3:13 · Deuteronomy 30:12–13

Go Deeper

If this verse has been used to put weight on you that it was never carrying, ask about it directly.

Ask Grace about this verse Get the free chapter All of Proverbs 30 Every chapter